When Mayor Joe Riley sent letters to citizens of the Town of James Island asking them to annex into the City of Charleston, he said that residents of the City pay less than nonresidents on their water and sewer bills. This was, at best, a half truth. (About a 1/3truth really, and I would think that all Citadel grads would remember the meaning of quibble.)
Mayor Riley was implying that by annexing to the City, it would be possible to lower the sewer and water bill. However, James Islanders have all heard the stories of long time residents who bought a new house in one of the City sections of James Island. They always gripe about their sky high water bill.
What is the solution to this mystery?
Citizens of the Town of James Island receive water from the Charleston Water System, which belongs to the City of Charleston. However, we receive waste water services from the James Island Public Service District. It is true that the City of Charleston’s water system charges nonresidents more for both water and sewer, but citzens of the Town of James Island don’t get sewer services from the City of Charleston. The James Island Public District charges less for wastewater than the City charges its own residents.
| Wastewater Rates |
| Residental |
JIPSD |
|
CWS |
| Base Charge |
$12.70 |
|
$26.00 |
| Volume (per Ccf) |
$3.70 |
|
$6.30 |
| Cap |
$64.50 |
|
114.83 |
| Non-Metered |
$38.60 |
|
$43.01 |
| Non- Residental |
|
|
|
| Base Charge |
$12.70 |
|
$36.00 |
| Volume (First 17 per Ccf ) |
$3.70 |
|
$8.67 |
| Volume (Over 20 per Ccf) |
|
|
$5.75 |
| Cap |
|
|
$158.25 |
| Non-Metered |
38.6 |
|
$59.40
|
(These two billing systems are not directly comparable because the JIPSD charges its base rate and then charges for each CfC of wastewater, while the City of Charleston includes the first two CfC’s as part of the base rate. For the average household, using 7 CfC’s, the JIPSD comes out much less.)
To further complicate matters, the City of Charleston uses the Charleston Water System to collect its storm water utility, while the Town of James Island (and unincorporated Charleston County) collects a storm water utility on the property tax. The City of Charleston charges about double.
So, if the Town of James Island is forced to close for a time, citizens of the Town will be in unincorporated Charleston County. There will be no change in water, sewer or storm sewer rates. The water bills will be the same–the rates the City of Charleston charges to nonresidents. The sewer rates will be the same, the charges by the James Island P.S.D. And the storm sewer rates will be the same, going to the County exactly as before, though it won’t say “Town of James Island” storm water utility on the property tax bill.
If someone chooses to annex into the City of Charleston, they will see their Charleston Water System bill skyrocket. While the water portion will decrease, the sewer will show up on the bill, and it will be higher than the JIPSD bill. And a storm water utility will also appear water bill, which will be more than the amount that will no longer show up on the property tax.
What will the end result be? Not the savings implied by Mayor Riley.